Inheritance and Probate

Follow us

Related Stories

Claims – Fear of Going to Court

Paulina has been working in one of the busiest branches of a large German supermarket for 8 years. She was employed as a retail assistant. In March 2018 Paulina was asked to restock the milk fridges. She had to push a large, 1.8m high, trolley full of milk cartons...

Claims – Fear of Solicitor’s Fees

Marek has suffered from a severe nut allergy all his life. His family never ordered takeaway food just in case it contained nuts. This changed during the lockdown in April and May of 2020. Marek’s family decided to order food from a local takeaway. On the phone, they...

Forgotten Daughter Awarded 60% of Father’s Estate

by | Aug 9, 2021 | Case Studies, News, Probate and Wills | 0 comments

Paul worked as an electrician for Dublin City Council for his entire life. He lived at home with his mother and never married. When he died, on his own, he left a will in which he left his house to his favourite nephew and the money in his bank accounts to be divided amongst his three surviving brothers.

Paul’s brother Brian was appointed executor of the will. Stephen the nephew asked and was let move into the house. He started renovating and modernising the house.

Probate was applied for. The Revenue were informed of the beneficiaries and of the tax payable by the nephew and the brothers. A court order called a Grant of Probate issued to allow Brian as executor to obtain the monies from the banks and officially transfer the house to Stephen, the favourite nephew.

Then the unexpected happened. Five months after the court order issued a letter was received from a Scottish firm of solicitors stating that they acted for Simone who, they stated, was the biological daughter of the deceased, Paul. They asked for a copy of the will and Grant of Probate. A subsequent letter arrived from an Irish firm of solicitors stating that as Simone was Paul’s only child and that she was entitled to all his estate.

Brian was flabbergasted!  Upon enquiry there was some knowledge within the family that Paul had visited relatives in Scotland and had met a girl at a dance and had a brief affair with her. Paul also used to send money and gifts to this lady. But no child had ever been acknowledged.

The law is that no child has an automatic right to inherit a set amount from their parents. However, section 117 of the Succession Act provides that a child, including an adult child, of a deceased parent who has made a will can apply to court and claim that the parent failed in his “moral duty to make proper provision for the child” in accordance with the parent’s means. An application must be made to the court within 6 months from the date of the issue of the Grant of Probate.

Court proceedings were issued by Simone 5 months after the Grant of Probate issued.

Brian could not accept that the will made by his brother Paul could be torn up and rewritten. The court proceedings got nasty. Brian insisted that Simone undergo a DNA test. Simone underwent the DNA test and it proved that she was Paul’s daughter. Simone had to set out for the court how she had got on in life and her current economic situation. It turned out Simone had not gone to university but had worked with the same large bank since leaving secondary school. She had a young family and was living in rented accommodation.

Brian was advised that Simone, as the only child of Paul, was likely to get at lease 80% of the Estate from the court. Coming up to the hearing of the case negotiations were entered into between the parties. It was agreed that Simone would get 60% of the estate and the remaining 40% of the Estate would be divided amongst the three brothers of the deceased and the nephew equally. The nephew was repaid the renovation monies for the house. The house was put up for sale. The Revenue were informed of the new beneficaries.  The nephew and his family received 10% of the value of the Estate. Nobody was very happy, but it was the best that could be done in the circumstances. If Paul had acknowledged his daughter in his will it could have averted a costly court case for his brothers and nephew.

If this story affected you or you have a similar concern please contact us.

Please note for privacy and GDPR reasons names and circumstances have been changed to protect the identity of the individuals involved.

John Griffin profile photo landscape

Need help with probate?

There is not a lot that John hasn't seen over the years. Let us help you.

Email John

John Griffin

Follow us
Google Reviews
Olga R.
Olga R.
09:42 28 May 21
After the loss of a loved one it can be very overwhelming, an then come all the legalities, probate etc, this is where... John an the team took all the stress an strain out of the process for us quickly an efficiently. We are extremely grateful to all the team at Griffin more
Ciaran B.
Ciaran B.
15:36 09 Apr 21
Very good to deal with on probate and wills. Would recommend
Louise W.
Louise W.
15:14 18 Mar 21
My husband and I have been using Griffin Solicitors for over twenty years. From purchasing property to drawing up our... wills to general legal queries John Griffin and his team have been unfailingly professional, prompt, polite and extremely efficient.Any matter is dealt with in a timely and expert manner.John Griffin leads a fantastic team who provide a superb professional service.We would highly recommend Griffin Solicitors for all your legal needs.A company that delivers outstanding service. .A pleasure to do business with them.Louise&Alan Weberread more
Share This

Share This

Share this post with your friends!